---
title: Impact Sprint {{NN}} — Spine beat · {{date:YYYY-MM-DD}}
type: log
project: leap-of-faith-labs
tags: [type/log, project/lofl, impact-sprint, "sprint/{{NN}}", spine, lofl-deliberation, pillar/3]
source: lofl-deliberation — one beat of the M&E Spine at the sprint's cadence
created: "{{date:YYYY-MM-DD}}"
updated: "{{date:YYYY-MM-DD}}"
status: seed
---

# Deliberation: {{claim in a few words}}

*Copy this file once per cadence tick into `spine/` as `03-beat-{{date}}.md`. The Spine is a rhythm, not a dashboard — cadence you chose, over the lenses you chose, five fields every time, Dissent surfaced and never averaged. The format is `lofl-deliberation`'s, verbatim; the sprint adds the promise check and the carried-dissent ledger beneath it.*

**Scale:** {{Intra-personal (self) / Inter-personal (witness of: <promise id>)}}
**Cycle / Date:** Sprint {{NN}} · beat {{k}} of {{K}} · {{date}}
**Lens-scope:** {{the lenses this beat covers — from `_index.md`; name the guardrail lens}}

## Position
{{the claim — one thing that could be wrong; if this is a selection of metric/lenses, state it as a choice being defended}}

## Evidence
- {{grounds: trace / observation / artefact — paths, not adjectives}}
- **IRIS+ metric (noun):** {{standard metric}} · **SDG(s):** {{aligned goals}}   ← noun, not a score

## Counter-Argument (steelmanned)
{{the strongest case against the Position — made in good faith. If you cannot write one, the Position is not yet a claim.}}

## Consensus
{{what holds after the argument — real agreement only}}

## Dissent
{{what did NOT resolve — surfaced and kept. Do not average it away. If none, say so and ask whether the Counter was strong enough.}}

---

## Promises checked this beat (a set — never a percentage)
| Promise | Claim (short) | Due | This beat: artifact present / absent / superseded | Pointer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| {{P1}} | {{…}} | {{date}} | {{present — path / absent — since when / superseded → Pn}} | {{…}} |
| {{P2}} | | | | |

*An absent artifact is written as absent with the date it became overdue. It is not a red number; it is a sentence. "No recorded completion status" is a legitimate entry and a signal.*

## Held dissents (carried forward from earlier beats)
| Dissent | Raised | Falsification condition | This beat |
|---|---|---|---|
| {{…}} | {{beat date}} | {{"if X by Y, the counter becomes the position"}} | {{untested — why / tested — what happened / closed — by what evidence}} |

*A dissent carried twice untested is itself a finding: name what would have tested it and who did not do it.*

## Witness (Envelope — optional, only if a witness observed this cycle)
Witness: {{name}} · their five fields about *their observation* of the promise live in a separate inter-personal beat: `03-beat-{{date}}-witness-{{name}}.md`. Same grammar, other scale. Never merged into this one.

## Register stub (for /lofl-doc-flow)
`Tend · {{date:YYYY-MM-DD}} · impact-sprint-{{NN}} beat {{k}} · lenses: {{…}} · promises: {{set}} · dissent carried: {{n named}} · next beat: {{date}}`

## Related
[[../_index]] · [[../01-promise-charter]] · [[lofl-deliberation]] · [[lofl-promise-ledger]]
